Constructive Discharge California

In California, the legal doctrine of constructive termination – also called constructive discharge or constructive dismissal – holds an employer accountable for creating or permitting intolerable conditions for an employee that the employee feels no choice but to resign from the job.

What is constructive discharge in California?

Constructive discharge occurs when an employer intentionally creates an intolerable work environment, compelling an employee to resign. In California, establishing a claim for constructive discharge requires meeting a relatively high standard of proof. Recognizing the signs of constructive discharge after resigning can be crucial for employees seeking legal remedies for wrongful termination. Constructive termination applies to contract employees and California’s at-will employees.

While the employee was not fired traditionally, they, along with their attorney, may be able to prove that they were unlawfully discharged based on the negligent actions of their employer.

To establish a claim of constructive discharge in California, an employee must prove the following elements:

Intolerable working conditions: Constructive discharge occurs when an employer in California purposefully creates intolerable and difficult working conditions for the entity’s employees. The working conditions must have been so severe that a reasonable employee in the same position would find them unbearable.

Employer’s intent or knowledge: The employer either intended to force the employee to resign or was aware that the working conditions were likely to result in the employee’s resignation.

Employee’s resignation: The employee must show that they actually resigned as a direct result of the intolerable working conditions. When an employer in California knowingly makes a job environment harsh and unbearable, this action results in employee resignations. However, when workers feel compelled to quit, they may be able to legally claim that their employer forced them out and willingly committed constructive dismissal.

While each case is unique and fact-specific, some examples of situations that may support a claim of constructive discharge include:

Repeated instance of shouting at an employee: Sustained verbal abuse, including yelling and berating, can contribute to an intolerable work environment.

Continuing episodes of disparagement or intimidation: Persistent disparaging remarks or intimidation tactics aimed at an employee can create a hostile workplace.

Badgering and harassment: Consistent harassment that causes emotional distress and negatively impacts job performance can lead to constructive discharge.

Reduction in employee’s responsibilities: A deliberate and unjustified reduction in an employee’s responsibilities or duties can contribute to a hostile work environment.

Unreasonable, unfair performance evaluations: Providing consistently unfair or unreasonably negative performance evaluations without justification can be indicative of constructive discharge.

Placing the worker at risk of harm: Assigning an employee to work on a project or task that poses a risk to their physical safety can be evidence of a hostile work environment.

Changing shifts and hours: Drastic and unreasonable changes in an employee’s shifts or working hours without legitimate reasons may contribute to an intolerable workplace.

Transfer to a far-away department or branch: A transfer to a distant location, making the commute burdensome, could be considered part of a strategy to force an employee to quit.

It is important to note that no single example on its own would automatically establish a claim of constructive discharge. Proving constructive discharge requires demonstrating that these actions were part of a pattern of intentional mistreatment aimed at forcing the employee to resign.

On the other hand, the courts in California have ruled that certain acts, such as a mere cut in hours, pay, or benefits, a solitary episode of mistreatment, or the promotion of other employees without evidence of discriminatory or retaliatory motives, do not necessarily support a claim of constructive discharge.

As constructive discharge cases are highly case-specific, employees seeking to pursue such claims should consult with an experienced employment attorney in California. An attorney can assess the particular circumstances, gather relevant evidence, and guide the employee through the complex process of pursuing legal remedies for constructive discharge.

Many constructive discharge cases can be challenging to prove, as the burden of proof rests on the employee to demonstrate that the employer deliberately created the intolerable conditions. Employees should carefully document any incidents, actions, or changes in the workplace that contributed to their decision to resign.

Constructive discharge is considered a form of wrongful termination, and if an employee successfully proves their claim, they may be entitled to remedies such as back pay, front pay (if the employee has not found a new job), emotional distress damages, and possibly attorney’s fees.

If you believe you have experienced constructive discharge, it is a good idea to consult with an experienced employment attorney in California to assess the circumstances of your case and explore your legal options.

When is quitting considered constructive discharge?

In California, employees are protected by laws that prohibit employers from engaging in unjust and harmful practices to force an employee to quit their job. Quitting under such circumstances, known as constructive discharge, occurs when the employer creates an unbearable work environment, compelling the employee to resign. While California follows the “at-will” employment doctrine, allowing both employers and employees to terminate the employment relationship at any time, constructive discharge presents an exception to this general rule.

Various scenarios can give rise to constructive discharge:

Unjustified reduction in hours or pay: If your employer significantly reduces your work hours or cuts your pay without valid reasons, this could lead to constructive discharge.

Mistreatment, harassment, intimidation, retaliation, or discrimination: Enduring mistreatment, harassment, intimidation, retaliation, or discrimination from an employer can make the working conditions intolerable and force an employee to consider quitting.

No worker should tolerate such treatment, and they have legal options to protect their rights. But when faced with these difficult situations, employees may wonder about the consequences of quitting and what legal rights they might retain:

Surrendering Legal Rights: If an employee voluntarily resigns, they may give up certain rights that they would have retained had they been terminated by the employer.
Unemployment Benefits: In most cases, if you quit your job, you may not be eligible for unemployment benefits, which are typically available to employees who are terminated involuntarily.
Wrongful Termination Claims: By resigning, you may lose the right to file a wrongful termination claim against your employer, even if the reasons for your resignation were linked to unlawful actions by the employer.

However, it is essential to note that constructive discharge cases can provide an exception to these essential rules. If you can prove that your resignation was a direct result of the employer’s actions, such as discrimination or retaliation, you may still have legal grounds to pursue a wrongful termination claim.

In California, even though it is an “at-will” employment state, certain exceptions exist. For instance:

- Employment Discrimination: Even “at-will” employees can pursue claims based on discrimination in employment if they were fired due to their race, age, gender, disability, or other characteristic that is legally protected.
- Employment Contracts: Employees who work under contract or work under specific time periods may have different rules and protections.

If you believe you are facing intolerable working conditions or have been subject to mistreatment, harassment, or discrimination, do not hesitate to consult with an experienced employment attorney. They can assess your situation, guide you on your rights, and help you pursue appropriate legal action if warranted. No employee should feel compelled to endure such conditions, and legal recourse may be available to ensure fair treatment in the workplace.

How do you prove a constructive discharge claim?

Proving a constructive discharge claim in California can be challenging, as it requires demonstrating that the working conditions were so intolerable that a reasonable employee would feel compelled to resign. To build a strong case, consider the following steps:

Document the working conditions: Keep a detailed record of incidents, actions, or changes in the workplace that contributed to the intolerable conditions. This documentation should include dates, times, locations, individuals involved, and descriptions of what occurred.

Seek support from colleagues: If other employees experienced similar issues or witnessed the conditions that led to your resignation, gather statements or testimonies from them to corroborate your claims.

Report the issues internally: If possible, report the intolerable working conditions to your employer’s human resources department or higher management. Keep a record of any complaints you make and the responses received.

Review employment policies: Familiarize yourself with your employer’s policies and procedures, especially regarding discrimination, harassment, or any other relevant workplace issues. If the employer violated its own policies, it can strengthen your case.

Gather evidence of discriminatory or retaliatory motives: If the intolerable conditions were linked to discriminatory or retaliatory actions, gather evidence supporting these claims, such as emails, messages, or witness statements.

Consult an employment attorney: Seek advice from an experienced employment attorney in California. They can help assess the strength of your case, guide you through the legal process, and advise you on the best course of action.

Preserve communications: Ensure you have copies of any relevant emails, text messages, or other communications related to the issues at hand.

Obtain medical records: If the intolerable working conditions resulted in mental or physical health issues, seek medical attention and keep records of medical visits related to these problems.

Show lack of reasonable alternatives: Demonstrate that you exhausted all reasonable options before deciding to resign, such as seeking internal remedies, discussing the issues with supervisors or human resources, or attempting to transfer to a different department.

Obtain witness statements: If there were witnesses to the intolerable conditions or any incidents that contributed to your resignation, obtain written or recorded statements from them.

Remember that each constructive discharge case is unique, you should contact a employment law litigation attorney about your specific circumstances. An experienced employment attorney will be best equipped to assess your case, gather relevant evidence, and advocate on your behalf to protect your rights under California employment law.

Is constructive discharge legal in California?

When employers in California force their workers to quit and use the following behaviors, the employers commit constructive discharge:

Mistreatment
Retaliation
Discrimination
Intimidation

Employers who refuse to fire employees outright may try other tactics, such as cutting employees’ hours or lowering their pay. For example, if an employee goes from 40 to 10 hours per week and cannot pay his or her bills, they may feel they have to leave their job.

Many workers feel trapped when confronted with this type of behavior by an employer. They worry that quitting will mean they give up their legal rights. Employees whose employers are mistreating or intimidating them also wonder when they can take action against their employer. For example, does an employee have to be legally separated from the business to take legal action against it?

Since California is an at-will working state, businesses can fire workers for any given reason and do not need to provide advance notice or explanation.

The other side of this at-will policy in California is that employees can quit their jobs whenever they want, and they do not need to provide notice or justification to their employers.

However, there exist exceptions to these rules. For example, the employer’s at-will status may have been violated if an employee can prove that they were terminated based on discrimination.

If an employer fires an at-will worker because of a protected characteristic, they can file a discrimination claim. These characteristics include:

Age
Race
Disability
Gender
Origin
Sex
Religion

Workers who possess employment contracts or who work for a specific amount of time also present as exceptions to the rule.

The main difference between an at-will employee who is terminated and an employee who is constructively dismissed is: employees who are constructively terminated give up specific rights that those fired as at-will workers hold onto.

When workers are constructively dismissed, they may find themselves ineligible to:

File for employment benefits
File a wrongful termination claim

Understanding the differences between employers who terminate at-will employees and those who constructively dismiss their workers helps California workers understand their rights.

The similarity between constructive discharge and wrongful termination is that the employment relationship ends. The difference between constructive discharge and wrongful termination depends on who terminates the employment relationship. When an employer wrongfully ends the employment relationship, it is a wrongful termination. A constructive termination occurs when the workplace condition causes an employee to terminate an employment relationship.

When illegal termination occurs, informed employees may be able to collect damages because their employer fired them for unlawful reasons.

What are unlawful reasons for termination? In California, under the state’s Fair Employment and Housing Act (FEHA), it is illegal to terminate an employee because of their:

Sexual orientation
Gender
Origin
Color
Age
Physical disability
Mental disability
Participation in an Official Investigation Against the Employer
Pregnancy
Religion
Other guidelines designated by state and federal law

Therefore, in California, employees who fall under these protected characteristics have a path for legal action. However, the workers usually need to have been terminated. If an employee quits and then tries to sue for wrongful termination, their claim will probably not achieve anything.

Constructive dismissal occurs when an employer creates a hostile work environment that leads the employee to quit. When the employer constructively terminates an employee, the employee can take advantage of a legal exception. However, since the employee is “forced” to quit, they may be able to sue the employer for their actions.

When an employer creates the conditions for constructive termination, they are effectively “firing” the employee, albeit indirectly.

Why is constructive discharge important?

Constructive discharge is a legal doctrine in California that protects employees from facing unjust consequences when they feel compelled to resign due to unbearable and unlawful working conditions. This doctrine recognizes that quitting should not automatically result in employees losing their remedies and legal rights, especially when employers intentionally create an environment designed to force an employee to quit.

Protecting Employee Rights: Constructive discharge safeguards employees’ rights and ensures that they are not left without legal recourse when they face unlawful and discriminatory actions at the workplace. It recognizes that employees should not be forced to endure intolerable conditions and have the right to seek remedies if they are pushed to resign due to an employer’s misconduct.

Combating Unlawful Practices: By recognizing constructive discharge, the law discourages employers from engaging in discriminatory and retaliatory actions that could lead to employees feeling compelled to quit. Employers are more likely to think twice before creating hostile work environments or engaging in unlawful practices if they know that their actions may still be subject to legal consequences, even if the employee resigns.

Equal Treatment for Resigned Employees: Treating constructive discharge as equivalent to an involuntary termination ensures that employees who resign due to intolerable working conditions are not unfairly disadvantaged compared to those who are terminated outright. This legal principle promotes fairness and equal protection under the law for all employees.

Encouraging Reporting of Wrongful Actions: Recognizing constructive discharge encourages employees to come forward and report instances of discrimination, harassment, and retaliation without fear of losing their rights if they decide to resign. It supports a work environment where employees feel empowered to assert their rights and hold employers accountable for unlawful practices.

Complex and Comprehensive Legal Protection: Constructive discharge cases can be intricate and challenging to navigate, requiring substantial evidence to prove the employer’s intent and the severity of the working conditions. By seeking the expertise of a constructive discharge lawyer in California, employees gain access to comprehensive legal protection and representation in their pursuit of justice and compensation.
Deterring Unlawful Employer Behavior: The availability of constructive discharge as a legal remedy deters employers from trying to exploit the “at-will” employment status by creating hostile conditions to force employees out. This creates a safer and more equitable work environment, promoting respect for employee rights and dignity.

What are the elements of wrongful termination in California?

Proving that constructive discharge occurred can challenge both the employee and their attorney. Workers must prove three aspects of the case to succeed with their claim for wrongful termination.

California employees must prove that:

Their employer sought to terminate the worker for discriminatory, unlawful, or retaliatory reasons

The worker had no choice but to resign because the workplace conditions were hostile and made normal work impossible.

The employer attempted to force the worker to quit by creating an intolerable and unbearable workplace.

California employees wondering if their work environments qualify as hostile should take note: it is not enough that their workplace is unfriendly or disagreeable. It is not enough if the worker does not enjoy working at the office or job site.

The workplace must be insufferable enough that any worker in the same position would leave. Additionally, the company must be aware—and shown to be aware—of the workplace conditions. For example, if the workplace was hostile, but the supervisor or CEO had no idea, it may become difficult to prove a constructive dismissal claim.

Also, the employer must have been aware that the employee found the working conditions hostile and unbearable and then did nothing about it.

While it is not vital for the worker to show that their employer acted in a retaliatory way, they need to show that the company was aware of intolerable conduct. For example, if discriminatory behavior occurred often, and the employer was aware of the taunting and racial slurs, but did nothing about it, the case for constructive dismissal could be successful.

What are examples of constructive discharge in California?

When employers force employees to leave their jobs, they should be able to recognize the clues that their dismissal was both constructive and possibly illegal.

In California, it can be difficult for employees to prove that they quit their job because they were forced out and had no other choice. However, here are some examples of employer behavior that typically qualifies as constructive termination.

Repeatedly yelling at and badgering employees
Intimidating workers repeatedly with insults and curses
Any type of repeated harassment, be it physical or verbal
Harassment that is overtly sexual
A sudden and dramatic reduction in employee responsibilities
A sudden change in work hours or location
Unfair performance evaluations that aren’t factual
Placing an employee at risk of physical injury through an assignment
Transferring a worker to a distant branch or department for no reason
Repeatedly making discriminatory comments against a worker

While all these actions are offensive, we cannot suggest that they will lead to a successful constructive discharge claim. On the contrary, these cases are highly subjective and based on individual circumstances.

However, if individuals keep careful records of their employer’s harmful actions and have trusted witnesses to present, their claim will have a better chance of success. For example, if a worker is repeatedly berated by their superior, they should gather witnesses and ask if they are willing to support them. Likewise, if an employer moves a worker’s desk for no reason, they can keep a record of this and even take pictures of the environmental change.

On the other hand, California courts also establish that some claims, if unaccompanied by other evidence or witnesses, will not be validated. The following evidential claims do not suffice for workers who deign to claim constructive dismissal:

Demotion at work
Lowering of pay
A change in hours or benefits
Promotions of employees
One single episode of mistreatment, not a pattern
Other acts that may not qualify

When individuals are unsure whether it makes sense to make a constructive claim, the best thing they can do is consult with an experienced wrongful termination attorney. At Nakase Wade, we offer free initial consultations and can help you figure out if the conditions are right to begin an employment law case.

Most recent blogs:

How to Calculate FTE

To calculate full-time equivalent (FTE), divide an employee's scheduled hours by the employer's hours for a full-time workweek.

Weingarten Rights

Understand Weingarten Rights: the right to have a representative during investigatory interviews as protected under the NLRA. Learn how these rights empower employees and safeguard their interests.

Can you get fired for using sick time

Understand your rights under California's Sick Leave Statute, protecting employees who need to take time off due to illness. Learn how legal protections safeguard against wrongful termination for using sick leave.

Insubordination in the workplace: 7 ways to manage

Navigate the challenges of insubordination in the workplace with effective strategies for managing difficult employee behaviors and fostering a positive work environment. Learn the importance of distinguishing between disagreement and insubordination for organizational health.

Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion

Explore the importance of diversity, equity, and inclusion in today's society. Learn how these values shape better, more inclusive communities and workplaces.

Human Resources (HR): Meaning and Responsibilities

Human Resources plays a pivotal role in recruiting, training, and managing employee relations, shaping a company's workforce for success. Discover the evolving responsibilities and strategic importance of HR in modern business dynamics.

10 Alternatives to Employee of the Month Awards

Discover the limitations of traditional Employee of the Month awards and explore ten innovative alternatives. Boost morale and recognition in your workplace with these creative solutions.

Learning To Learn

Discover the essential skills for modern leaders to thrive: learning to learn, adapting to change, and mastering new capabilities. Unveil strategies for personal growth and overcoming reluctance to embrace new challenges.

Gen Z Years, Age Range, Meaning, & Characteristics

Explore the defining years, age range, and unique characteristics of Generation Z, shaped by pivotal events like the pandemic and the digital age. Uncover insights into Gen Z's diverse demographics, digital nativity, and shifting social norms.

Quid Pro Quo Sexual Harassment and Law

Explore the origin and evolution of "quid pro quo," a principle that embodies mutual exchange in legal, political, and everyday contexts. Learn how it differentiates from bribery and shapes contracts, policies, and workplace ethics.

What is Sabbatical Leave? It’s the best kept secret in HR

Unlock the power of sabbatical leave to boost employee motivation and retention in a stagnating labor market. Learn how a planned break can give your company a competitive edge in attracting top talent.

At-Will Doctrine

Explore the at-will employment doctrine's impact on job security and termination rights in the US, highlighting key legal exceptions. Understand how at-will affects both employers and employees, with insights into valid termination causes and protections.

7-Day Work Week

Discover your rights under the 7-day work week laws, including eligibility for overtime and restrictions in some states. Learn about federal and state regulations, and when to seek legal action for wage violations.

What Happens When Employers Make False Promises

A false promise happens when a employer or hiring manager makes a statement on something the company can fulfill or avoid, but cannot or does not want to follow through with. You may bring a fraudulent inducement lawsuit against the employer for false promises for the harm you have suffered.

What to do if your employer doesn’t pay you?

If your employer failed to pay you for all of your work hours, a court could award you back pay. When your employer doesn't pay you, you should consult with an employment lawyer.

What to Do At a Job Fair to Impress Employers and Get the Interview

This article provides guidelines for job seekers to follow to ensure they are successful at career fairs. There are many things you can do to improve your chances of getting hired at a job fair.

Emotional Duress: How to Avoid

Emotional duress is an extremely unpleasant emotional response from someone else's conduct or actions. You can sue for money damages for anguish, or humiliation. This is known as emotional harm or mental anguish.

California Termination Laws

In California, an employee's employment may be terminated at the will of either party. Employees who are terminated must be paid all wages due at the time of termination.

Late Paycheck Penalty

When your paycheck is late, the employer has to pay a penalty of one day's pay for each day that the paycheck is late, up to a maximum of thirty days.

How To Calm Down Before An Interview

12 simple ways on to calm your nerves before and during an interview is to use relaxation techniques. Before an interview, imagine how you would ideally want to present yourself in the interview and then visualize yourself in the interview.

How to Include a Referral in Your Cover Letter?

Your cover letter should start with mentioning the referral's name because it instantly qualifies you. A referral cover letter helps you to define the mutual contact that has referred you for the job.

Best Job Options For Someone With A Criminal Record

This article identifies jobs for someone with a criminal record; examples are: delivery service, freelance designer, truck driver, chef, etc.

What are Weingarten Rights?

Weingarten rights guarantee an employee the right to Union representation during an investigatory interview by their employer.

What Is Job Rotation: Advantages And Disadvantages

Job rotation is the practice of moving employees between roles or positions in a company. Job rotation temporarily assigns employees to other roles to teach them new skills, learn about other functions within the team, and develop relationships across the business.

What is the meaning of Pay Rate?

Pay rate is the total money a worker receives during regular working hours, excluding overtime. In order words, pay rate, also called salary rate or compensation rate, is the wage amount paid to an employee per hour, per day, or per task completed.

How can part-time or temporary work help you explore career choices?

Part-time or temporary work offers a practical way to explore exploring and understanding what career you want. Temporary work or part time work gives you the opportunity to discover your strengths, preferences, and passions without the long-term commitment required by full-time work.

Understanding Incentive Pay: Definition, Types, and Benefits Explained

Learn how different forms of incentive pay, from bonuses to commission, can drive business success and enhance workforce engagement. Discover the key benefits and best practices of implementing incentive pay strategies in your organization, essential for attracting and retaining top talent.

What Happens When You Get Audited EDD

Gain clarity on the EDD audit process with our comprehensive guide, detailing what happens when you get audited by the Employment Development Department, including steps to prepare and respond effectively." "Navigate the complexities of an EDD audit smoothly with our expert insights, exploring the implications, documentation requirements, and key strategies to manage the auditing process efficiently and confidently.

What is FMLA Intermittent Leave of Absence?

An employee uses their 12 weeks of unpaid leave intermittently under FMLA Intermittent leave, taking it off and on, unlike continuous family medical leave or a reduced work schedule. FMLA leave can be taken intermittently by employees – in separate blocks of time for a single qualifying reason – or on a reduced leave schedule, which involves reducing the employee's usual weekly or daily work schedule, when it is medically necessary.

What is a statutory employee?

A statutory employee is a salesperson, either traveling full-time or based in a city, who represents you and submits orders from wholesalers, retailers, contractors, or operators of establishments such as hotels and restaurants. The merchandise sold should be for resale, or the supplies should be for use in the buyer's business operation. For you, the principal business activity performed must be the salesperson's work.