Breach of Employment Contract by Employer

An employment contract breach can occur because the employer or employee breached a written contract, implied contract, or verbal contract. The employment contract sets out legally enforceable terms and conditions that govern the working relationship between the employer and employee.

Author: Douglas Wade, Attorney

Email  |  Call (800) 484-4610

An employment contract is “breached” when one party doesn’t live up to its end of the bargain. An employer may breach an employment contract by violating the terms of an employment contract with an employee. 

In this article, our California employment lawyer for employers will discuss breach of employment contract as follows:

Definition

An employer breaches an employment contract having a specified term if the employer terminates the contract prior to the expiration of the term without “good cause.” In this context, “good cause” means the employee’s willful breach of, habitual neglect of, or continued incapacity to perform his or her duties. (Cal. Lab. Code, §2924; see also BAJI 10.04, 10.31, 10.32.)

There is presumption of at-will employment if parties have made no express oral or written agreement specifying length of employment or grounds for termination; however, such presumption may be overcome by evidence that despite absence of specified term, parties agreed that employer’s power to terminate would be limited in some way, e.g., by requirement that termination be based only on “good cause.” (Cal. Lab. Code, §2922.)

“[L]abor Code section 2924 has traditionally been interpreted to ‘inhibit[] the termination of employment for a specified term except in case of a wilful breach of duty, of habitual neglect of, or continued incapacity to perform, a duty.’ ” (Khajavi v. Feather River Anesthesia Med. Grp. (2000) 84 Cal.App.4th 32, 57.)

Note: For a breach of employment contract, a termination may be either actual or constructive. A termination is actual when the employer tells the employee, orally or in writing, that the employment is terminated. (Turner v. Anheuser-Busch, Inc. (1994) 7 Cal. 4th 1238, 1244-45) In employment contract breach, a termination is constructive when the employee is effectively forced to resign due to intolerable working conditions that the employer either created or knowingly permitted. (Id. at p. 1246 [“a constructive discharge is legally regarded as a firing rather than a resignation.”]; see also BAJI 10.02.)

Elements of Breach of Employment Contract for a Specified Term

CACI No. 2420

For a breach of employment contract, the elements are:

[Name of plaintiff] claims that [name of defendant] breached an employment contract for a specified term. To establish this claim, [name of plaintiff] must prove all of the following:

  1. That [name of plaintiff] and [name of defendant] entered into an employment contract that specified a length of time that [name of plaintiff] would remain employed;
  2. That [name of plaintiff] substantially performed [his/her/nonbinary pronoun] job duties [unless [name of plaintiff]’s performance was excused [or prevented]];
  3. That [name of defendant] breached the employment contract by [discharging/demoting] [name of plaintiff] before the end of the term of the contract; and
  4. That [name of plaintiff] was harmed by the [discharge/demotion]

Element 1: Valid Employment Contract With Specified Term

A contract of employment is a contract by which one, the employer, engages another, the employee, to do something for the benefit of the employer or a third person. (See Cal. Lab. Code §2750; Cal. Civ. Code §1549.) A contract has a specified term of employment if it specifies a term that is greater than one month. (See Cal. Lab. Code §2922.)

In a breach of contract by employer, the plaintiff must prove the existence of a valid employment contract to prevail on a breach of employment contract claim. (Wise v. Southern Pacific Co. (1963) 223 Cal. App. 2d 50, 59.)

Employment contracts are governed by general contract law. (Reynolds v. Electric & Engineering Co. v. W.C.A.B. (1966) 55 Cal. 2d 429, 433 [“[a] contract of employment is governed by the same rules applicable to other types of contracts.”].)

The only proper defendant in a breach of employment contract action is the employer (a party to the employment relationship), not other employees. (See, e.g., Cleary v. American Airlines, Inc. (1980)111 Cal. App. 3d 433, 456 [co-workers were not liable for breach of implied covenant of good faith and fair dealing]; Shoemaker v. Myers (1990) 52 Cal. 3d 1, 25 [it is “well-established that corporate agents and employees acting for and on behalf of a corporation cannot be liable for inducing a breach of the corporation’s contract”].)

Generally, public employees may not assert breach of contract claims. (Miller v. State (1977) 18 Cal. 3d 808, 813.)

Element 2: Employee Substantially Performed Job Duties

Unless excused, the employee must demonstrate that he or she was performing his or her duties adequately. (Wise v. Southern Pacific Co. (1963) 223 Cal. App. 2d 50, 59; see also Cal. Civ. Code, §§1439-1440; Cal. Lab. Code, §§2854, 2856-2859.)

The plaintiffs bear the burden of proving that they stood ready to or actually did perform their duties adequately. (Wise v. Southern Pacific Co. (1963) 223 Cal. App. 2d 50, 59.)

The employees must not only use ordinary care and diligence in the performance of their duties, but also must substantially comply with all directions of their employers unless the directions are impossible, unlawful or would impose new and unreasonable burdens on the employees. (Cal. Lab. Code, §§2854, 2856.)

Moreover, to prove a breach of employment contract, the element of substantial performance should not be confused with the “good cause” defense: “The action is primarily for breach of employment contract. It was therefore incumbent upon plaintiff to prove that he was able and offered to fulfill all obligations imposed upon him by the contract. Plaintiff failed to meet this requirement; by voluntarily withdrawing from the contract he excused further performance by defendant.” (Kane v. Sklar (1954) 122 Cal.App.2d 480, 482; see also CACI No. 2420.)

Element 3: Discharge Before Term Expired

The employer must have discharged the employee before expiration of the term without good cause. (See Cal. Lab. Code, §2924; BAJI 10.04.)

The plaintiff must prove that the employer terminated his or her employment prior to the expiration of the contract term. (Wise v. Southern Pacific Co. (1963) 223 Cal. App. 2d 50, 59.)

The termination may be actual or constructive. (Turner v. Anheuser-Busch, Inc. (1994) 7 Cal. 4th 1238, 1244-45.)

To constitute a constructive discharge, the employee must prove that the employer either intentionally created or knowingly permitted working conditions that were so intolerable or aggravated at the time of the resignation that a reasonable employer would realize that a reasonable person in the employee’s position would be compelled to resign. (Turner v. Anheuser-Busch, Inc. (1994) 7 Cal. 4th 1238, 1251 [no constructive discharge in case alleging retaliatory wrongful termination and termination in violation of public policy].)

Element 4: Discharge Without “Good Cause”

Good cause exists if the employee’s willful breach, habitual neglect, or continued incapacity means that the employee does not perform the duties of employment. (Cal. Lab. Code, §2924; BAJI 10.32.)

In proving wrongful termination of a breach of employment contract with a specified term, the “good cause” needed is quite different from that necessary to prove wrongful termination of an implied contract not to discharge without good cause. (Pugh v. See’s Candies, Inc. (1981) 116 Cal. App. 3d 311, 330.)

An employment contract may set forth a different standard for termination than that provided for in Labor Code §2924. (See, e.g., R.J. Cardinal Co. v. Ritchie (1963) 218 Cal. App. 2d 124, 143 [“A contract may contain a valid provision giving one or either of the parties thereto an option to terminate it within a certain time or on specified conditions.”].)

Element 5: Causation and Damages

In a breach of contract by employer, the termination must cause the employee damage. (Wise v. Southern Pacific Co. (1963) 223 Cal. App. 2d 50, 59; Cal. Civ. Code, §3300; see also BAJI 10.04.)

“The plaintiff has the burden of proving his damage. The law is settled that he has the duty of minimizing that damage. While the contract wages are prima facie [evidence of] his damage, his actual damage is the amount of money he was out of pocket by reason of the wrongful discharge.” (Erler v. Five Points Motors, Inc. (1967) 249 Cal.App.2d at pp. 567-568.)

Remedies


Contract Damages

Contract damages are of two types – general damages (sometimes called direct damages) and special damages (sometimes called consequential damages). (Lewis Jorge Construction Management, Inc. v. Pomona Unified School Dist. (2004) 34 Cal.4th 960, 968.)

“Contract damages are generally limited to those within the contemplation of the parties when the contract was entered into or at least reasonably foreseeable by them at that time; consequential damages beyond the expectation of the parties are not recoverable. This limitation on available damages serves to encourage contractual relations and commercial activity by enabling parties to estimate in advance the financial risks of their enterprise.’ ‘In contrast, tort damages are awarded to [fully] compensate the victim for [all] injury suffered.” (Erlich v. Menezes (1999) 21 Cal.4th 543, 550.)

Equitable Remedies Not Available

The obligation to employ another in personal service cannot be specifically enforced. (Cal. Civ. Code, §3390.)

Punitive Damages Not Available

California courts do not recognize a right to punitive or exemplary damages for breach of employment contract, unless the breach occurs in connection with an intentional tort. (Foley v. Interactive Data Corp. (1988) 47 Cal. 3d 654, 700.)

Emotional Distress Damages Typically Not Available

Cases permitting recovery for emotional distress typically involve mental anguish stemming from more personal undertakings the traumatic results of which were unavoidable. Thus, when the express object of the contract is the mental and emotional well-being of one of the contracting parties, the breach of the contract may give rise to damages for mental suffering or emotional distress. (Erlich v. Menezes (1999) 21 Cal.4th 543, 559.)

Attorney’s Fees if Provided For in Employment Contract

“In the absence of a statute authorizing attorneys’ fees as an element of damages, or of a contract to pay such fees in event of the party’s recovery, attorneys’ fees paid by a successful party in an action are never recoverable against the unsuccessful party.” (Jen–Mar Constr. Co. v. Brown (1967) 247 Cal.App.2d 564, 573; Cal. Code Civ. Proc., § 1021.)

Statute of Limitations

The statute of limitations for breach of a written employment contract is four years. (Cal. Civ. Proc. Code, §337(1).) The limitations period for breach of an oral contract is two years. (Cal. Civ. Proc. Code, §339(1).) If you are alleging tortious breach of contract causing personal injury, then the statute of limitations is two years. Note: Prior to 2003, the statute of limitations for personal injury actions was one year from the date of injury. (Cal. Civ. Proc. Code, §340.) Effective January 1, 2003, the new Code of Civil Procedure §335.1 extends the statute of limitations to two years.

Affirmative Defenses

Good Cause Defense

Plaintiff claims a breach of employment contract. An employer is justified in discharging his employee, when the latter fails to perform his duty, even though injury does not result to the employer as a result of the employee’s failure to do his duty. (Bank of America National Trust & Savings Ass’n v. Republic Productions, Inc. (1941) 44 Cal.App.2d 651, 654.)

“To terminate an employment without the expiration of its contractual term ‘there must be good cause.’ The grounds for terminating such an employment are stated in Labor Code section 2924…. It is therefore not every deviation of the employee from the standard of performance sought by his employer that will justify a discharge. There must be some ‘wilful act or wilful misconduct…’ when the employee uses his best efforts to serve the interests of his employer.” (Holtzendorff v. Housing Authority of the City of Los Angeles (1967) 250 Cal.App.2d 596, 610.)

“An employment agreement that specifies the length of employment (e.g., two years) limits the employer’s right to discharge the employee within that period. Unless the agreement provides otherwise (e.g., by reserving the right to discharge for cause), the employer may terminate employment for a specified term only for [the grounds specified in Labor Code section 2924].” (See CACI No. 2421.)

Elements of the Good Cause Defense for Breach of Employment Contract for a Specified Term; CACI No. 2421

Daniel claims that he did not breach the employment contract because he fired Paula for good cause. To establish good cause, Daniel must prove: (1) that Paula willfully breached a job duty; or (2) that Paula continually neglected her job duties; or (3) that a continued incapacity prevented Paula from performing her job duties.

Employee’s Duty to Mitigate Damages

Employee claims that the employer breach of contract. “[T]he contract compensation for the unexpired period of the contract affords a prima facie measure of damages; the actual measured damage, however, is the contract amount reduced by compensation received during the unexpired term; if, however, such other compensation has not been received, the contract amount may still be reduced or eliminated by a showing that the employee, by the exercise of reasonable diligence and effort, could have procured comparable employment and thus mitigated the damages.” (Erler v. Five Points Motors, Inc. (1967) 249 Cal.App.2d 560, 562.)

Plaintiff claims a employment contract breach. “The burden of proof is on the party whose breach caused damage, to establish matters relied on to mitigate damage.” (Steelduct Co. v. Henger-Seltzer Co. (1945) 26 Cal.2d 634, 654.)

Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment

Most recent blogs:

Double Time California- When Employers Are Required to Pay Twice the Regular Hourly Rate and How It Is Calculated

Double Time California: When Employers Are Required to Pay Twice the Regular Hourly Rate and How It Is Calculated

California employers must pay double-time wages in situations like 12-hour shifts or working seven days without a break. This article covers who qualifies, common payroll mistakes, and how double-time compensation should be figured under California law.
Tip Pooling Rules in Every State- What Restaurant Owners Must Know

Tip Pooling Rules in Every State: What Restaurant Owners Must Know

Tip pooling laws vary by state, affecting how restaurants manage tips and comply with federal and local wage rules. Restaurant owners are required to follow guidelines to avoid fines, lawsuits, and disputes over tip distribution and service charges.
How Long Does an Employer Have to Pay You After Payday in California- Legal Timeframes, Rules, and Consequences

How Long Does an Employer Have to Pay You After Payday in California: Legal Timeframes, Rules, and Consequences

Employers in California must pay wages on time or face fines, including back pay and waiting time penalties for delayed checks. Employees may pursue compensation for late or missing pay through legal claims tied to payroll violations under state labor law.
CA Exempt Employee Classification- Definitions, Exemptions, and Legal Exposure for Employers

CA Exempt Employee Classification: Definitions, Exemptions, and Legal Exposure for Employers

Employers risk lawsuits and large settlements when CA workers are misclassified under state exemption rules. Roles must be reviewed regularly to match duties.
How to Get a Job at 14- Simple Steps for Teens Who Want to Start Working

How to Get a Job at 14: Simple Steps for Teens Who Want to Start Working

Many teens can get jobs at 14 with the right documents, clear goals, and a simple but effective resume. This article explains rules, permits, applications, interviews, and ways to stay focused during your first job search.
How Many Hours Can a 17-Year-Old Work in California During School Labor Rules You Should Know

How Many Hours Can a 17-Year-Old Work in California During School? Labor Rules You Should Know

California limits how many hours 17-year-olds can work during school to protect their safety, education, and wages. Know the labor rules that apply to minors and what families should do if employers violate state employment laws.
AB 1228 Summary - California Fast Food Law on Wages, Council Authority, and Business Impact

AB 1228 Summary: California Fast Food Law on Wages, Council Authority, and Business Impact

California's AB 1228 law sets a $20 hourly wage for fast food workers and forms a state-level Fast Food Council. It changes employment rules, impacts exempt pay requirements, and raises business cost issues for restaurants and their customers.
Can a 13 Year Old Work - 14 Real Ways for Young Teens to Earn Money Safely

Can a 13 Year Old Work? 14 Real Ways for Young Teens to Earn Money Safely

A 13-year-old can safely earn money through creative, age-appropriate jobs like babysitting, pet care, or blogging. This guide lists 14 proven options that balance responsibility, fun, and parental supervision.
Severance Pay California - What It Includes and How to Change the Terms

Severance Pay California: What It Includes and How to Change the Terms

California severance pay is not legally required, but agreements often include pay, benefits, and legal waivers. Employees can negotiate terms, challenge clauses, and improve severance offers with legal or personal review.
Employment Litigation - Key Issues in Job Termination, Discrimination, and Harassment Cases

Employment Litigation: Key Issues in Job Termination, Discrimination, and Harassment Cases

Employees may sue for job termination, discrimination, or harassment when workplace actions violate federal or state employment rules. This article explains legal protections, common violations, and employee rights involved in workplace-related lawsuits.
Company Morale - 20 Practical Ways to Improve Workplace Culture and Engagement

Company Morale: 20 Practical Ways to Improve Workplace Culture and Engagement

Improve company morale with 20 practical tactics that strengthen workplace culture, boost motivation, and support everyday team interaction. Encourage positivity, increase retention, and support employee satisfaction through real-world practices designed for today's professional environment.
California Mileage Reimbursement 2025 - Rate Details, Methods, and Employer Duties

California Mileage Reimbursement 2025: Rate Details, Methods, and Employer Duties

California employers must reimburse staff for business-related vehicle use based on mileage rates or alternative approved methods. The 2025 policy outlines IRS rates, covered expenses, and mandatory employer responsibilities under California labor law.
Temporary Disability California - Workers’ Compensation Coverage, Benefit Limits, and Qualifying Conditions

Temporary Disability California: Workers’ Compensation Coverage, Benefit Limits, and Qualifying Conditions

Temporary disability in California pays part of your wages after a workplace injury confirmed by an approved medical provider. Eligibility, time limits, and payment amounts depend on work status, legal codes, employer options, and medical updates.
Legal Age to Work in 2025- Employment Limits for Minors

Legal Age to Work in 2025: Employment Limits for Minors

State and federal laws set age, hour, and job restrictions for minors working in 2025 to protect their safety. Review employment limits for children across all fifty states, including agricultural rules, certificates, and non-hazardous job requirements.
Abusive Conduct Under California Law- Definition, Workplace Examples, and Employer Obligations

Abusive Conduct Under California Law: Definition, Workplace Examples, and Employer Obligations

Abusive conduct in California workplaces includes bullying, hostile language, and exclusion that disrupts an employee's job performance. Employers must provide harassment prevention training and meet legal obligations under FEHA and Senate Bill No. 778.
Minimum Wage in San Diego 2025- Updated City and County Pay Rates for Employers

Minimum Wage in San Diego 2025: Updated City and County Pay Rates for Employers

Minimum wage in San Diego City is $17.25 per hour in 2025, while the county rate remains $16.50. Employers must comply with state, city, and county wage laws or face penalties for underpayment and related violations.
California Labor Law - 2025 Employer & Employee Guide to Wages, Breaks, Leave, and Rights

California Labor Law: 2025 Employer & Employee Guide to Wages, Breaks, Leave, and Rights

California’s 2025 labor laws address wages, breaks, overtime, workplace safety, discrimination, sick leave, and employee protections. This guide outlines rules on scheduling, payroll, final paychecks, paid sick time, and employment standards for minors.
California Final Paycheck Law - Payment Timelines, Legal Rules, and Employer Responsibilities

California Final Paycheck Law: Payment Timelines, Legal Rules, and Employer Responsibilities

California employers must follow exact final paycheck rules when employees quit or are fired, or risk paying penalty wages. The article covers payment timing, employer duties, and industry-specific exceptions including film, oil drilling, and agriculture.
Can You Work at 14 in California - Laws, Restrictions, and Permits for 14- and 15-Year-Olds

Can You Work at 14 in California? Laws, Restrictions, and Permits for 14- and 15-Year-Olds

Minors aged 14 can work in California, but strict federal and state labor laws limit hours, industries, and duties. Work permits are mandatory for 14- and 15-year-olds, and employment is subject to revocation if conditions are violated.
How Many Hours Is a 9-5 Job - Daily, Weekly, Monthly, and Yearly Breakdown

How Many Hours Is a 9-5 Job? Daily, Weekly, Monthly, and Yearly Breakdown

A 9–5 job typically means eight hours daily, totaling 40 hours weekly across five standard workdays. Monthly and yearly hours vary depending on vacations, with most averaging 160 monthly and 2,000 annually.
Exempt Employee California 2025 Rules, Salary Thresholds & Classification Tests Explained

Exempt Employee California: 2025 Rules, Salary Thresholds & Classification Tests Explained

California's 2025 exempt employee rules include new salary thresholds for fast food and healthcare workers under state wage laws. Detailed tests determine exemption status based on duties, salary structure, and consistent application of independent judgment.
Fair Chance Employers A 2025 Guide to Compliant and Inclusive Hiring Practices

Fair Chance Employers: A 2025 Guide to Compliant and Inclusive Hiring Practices

Fair chance hiring promotes compliance with evolving state and federal laws that support inclusive recruitment for applicants with records. Employers must assess convictions individually, follow proper procedures, and align background checks with job relevance and legal standards.
PAGA Claims in California How Workers Can File and What Penalties Employers Face

PAGA Claims in California: How Workers Can File and What Penalties Employers Face

Employees in California can file PAGA claims for labor violations and recover civil penalties on behalf of the state. Penalties vary by infraction, and employers may reduce liability if violations are corrected within the allowed timeframe.
How Many Hours Can a 16 Year Old Work A Complete Guide to U.S. Child Labor Laws

How Many Hours Can a 16 Year Old Work? A Complete Guide to U.S. Child Labor Laws

Federal law sets no limit on work hours for 16-year-olds, but many states impose restrictions and nighttime limits. This guide breaks down FLSA rules, state variations, job types, and penalties for violating child labor laws.
New Hire Forms Checklist- Required Documents & Onboarding Essentials for Employers

New Hire Forms Checklist: Required Documents & Onboarding Essentials for Employers

Manage new hire onboarding smoothly using this checklist of required federal, state, and internal employment documents. Meet compliance needs and simplify hiring by collecting tax forms, offer letters, benefits paperwork, and signed policy acknowledgments.
Comp Day Explained - Eligibility, Benefits, and How to Calculate It Correctly

Comp Day Explained: Eligibility, Benefits, and How to Calculate It Correctly

Comp day lets eligible employees take time off instead of receiving overtime pay, offering flexibility in work schedules. This article explains how comp time is calculated, who qualifies, and the differences between comp time and overtime rules.
Work Permit California - Requirements, Age Limits, and Job Restrictions for Minors

Work Permit California: Requirements, Age Limits, and Job Restrictions for Minors

Minors in California need a work permit to get jobs, with specific restrictions based on age, role, and school status. This article outlines age requirements, job limitations, working hours, and exceptions to the state’s work permit rules for minors.
Split Shift Meaning Explained - How It Works, Benefits, Laws, and Real-World Examples

Split Shift Meaning Explained: How It Works, Benefits, Laws, and Real-World Examples

Split shifts divide a workday into separate periods with a long unpaid break, boosting flexibility and reducing staffing costs. This schedule helps businesses meet demand during peak hours while supporting employee well-being and complying with labor laws.
Is California an At-Will State - 4 Key Exceptions You Need to Know

Is California an At-Will State? 4 Key Exceptions You Need to Know

California permits at-will employment, but specific exceptions restrict when employers may legally terminate an employee without explanation. Contracts, public policy, fraud, and fairness-based exceptions can provide legal grounds for challenging terminations.
California Pay Data Reporting - 2025 Deadline, New MENA Category, and Updated Filing Requirements

California Pay Data Reporting: 2025 Deadline, New MENA Category, and Updated Filing Requirements

The 2025 deadline for California pay data reporting brings updated requirements, including MENA classification and new employer obligations. Covered employers must submit demographic wage data by job role, gender, race, and pay band or face financial penalties.

Free Consultation