|
C Corp |
S Corp |
LLC |
Owners of business |
Shareholders |
Same as for C corporation |
Members |
Personal liability for business debts |
None for shareholders |
Same as for C corporation |
Members do not have any personal liability |
|
|
|
|
Restrictions on nature of business |
Formation of banking, insurance, and other special businesses prohibited in some states |
Same as for C corporation—however, if converted from C to S corporation, then excessive passive income (such as from rents, royalties, interest, etc.) can jeopardize tax status |
Same as for C corporation; some states prohibit performance of professional services |
Restrictions on number of owners |
One-person corporations permitted in most states allow one-person corporations; some states require two individuals to serve as officers |
Same as for C corporation, but with a maximum of 100 shareholders |
One member allowed (every state) |
Management decision-making |
Board of Directors |
Same as for C corporation |
As a rule, members; for a manager-managed LLC, can be managers instead |
Parties authorized by law to legal bind business |
Directors and Officers |
Same as for C corporation |
As a rule, any member; if a manager-managed LLC, can be managers |
Effect of death or separation of an owner |
No effect unless corporation is solely owned |
Same as for C corporation |
Dissolution unless remaining members votes to continue business (in a small number of states) |
Limitations on transfer of ownership interests |
Transfer of stock may be limited due to securities laws or restrictions placed in articles of incorporation or bylaws |
Same as for C corporation—but transfers are limited to persons and entities qualifying as S corporation shareholders |
Unanimous consent of non-transferring members possibly required by state law or by operating agreement |
Extent of organizational paperwork and ongoing legal formalities |
Filing for start is required; bylaws are recommended; annual meetings are required |
Same as for C corporation |
Filing is required for start-up; operation agreement is recommended; under normal circumstances, meetings are not required |
Funding source for start-up |
Initial shareholders (some states prohibit purchases of shares with a promise to perform services or to contribute cash in the future) |
Same as for C corporation—but it is not permitted to issue different classes of stock with different financial provisions |
Members (as a rule, they may invest with a promise to perform services or to contribute cash in the future) |
Usual method for business to obtain needed capital |
Flexible; outside investors permitted to buy various classes of shares; bank loans backed by shareholders’ personal assets (if corporation has insufficient credit history); permitted to go public (IPO) if substantial cash infusion is needed |
Generally same as for C corporation—but no foreign, partnership, or corporate shareholders permitted; number of shareholders must be limited to 100; different classes of stock to investors not permitted, except for shares having different voting rights |
Members make capital contributions from members; banks issue loans backed by members; personal assets (if LLC has insufficient credit history) |
Ease of conversion to another business form |
Change to S corporation permitted by filing simple tax election; change to LLC can involve tax costs and increased legal complexity |
Generally same as for C corporation—it is possible to terminate S tax status to become C corporation, but then S status cannot be elected again for five years |
Change permitted to general or limited partnership, or to corporation; legal paperwork involved |
Do federal and state securities laws apply to establishment or sale of ownership interests? |
Yes. Issuance or transfer of stock subject to state and federal securities laws, otherwise, it must qualify for exemptions under the exemptions provided by these securities laws |
Same as for C corporation |
No (probably), if all members are active in business |
Which type of owners prefer each form for doing business? |
Owners who want limited liability along with the ability to divide income between themselves and a separately taxed business |
Owners who want limited liability, along with application of individual tax rates to business income; must be willing to meet initial and ongoing S corporation requirements |
Generally, owners who want limited liability along with pass-through taxation; particularly beneficial for smaller, privately held businesses |
Taxation of business profits |
Divided and taxed at corporate rates and at the shareholders’ individual tax rates |
Individual tax rates of shareholders |
Individual tax rates of members |
Tax-deductible fringe benefits available to owners working in business |
Employee-shareholders can have tax-deductible fringe benefits; employees’ medical expenses can be reimbursed; tax-free term life insurance can be provided; stock equity plans can be established for employees |
Same as for general partnership; however, but employee-shareholders owning 2% or more of stock are restricted from receiving deductible corporate fringe benefits; equity-sharing plans generally not available |
Owners receive tax benefits associated with sole proprietorship (one-member LLCs) or partnership (multi-member LLCs) |
Automatic tax status |
Yes, upon filing Articles of Incorporation with the corporate filing office in the respective state |
No; requirement must be met, and tax election form filed with IRS (and sometimes corresponding state authority as well); revoked or terminated tax status cannot be chosen again for five years |
Yes, one-member LLC treated as sole proprietorship; multi-member LLC treated as partnership |
Payment of taxes due when business is formed? |
Generally not taxable if IRC Section 351 requirements are met |
Same as for C corporation |
Generally, setting up is tax free; individual income taxes may be due if a member contributes services as capital contribution |
Deductible of business losses |
Corporation is permitted to deduct business losses (shareholders may not deduct losses) |
Shareholders may deduct their respective shares of corporate losses on their individual tax returns, but must comply with passive loss limitation; normally, shareholders do not receive the tax benefit of entity-level debt |
Follows sole proprietorship or partnership rules, depending on tax status of LLC |
Tax level at time business is sold |
Two levels: shareholders and corporation may both be taxed on sale of business |
Normally taxed at personal tax levels of individual shareholders; however, corporate-level tax is sometimes due, if S corporation was formerly a C corp. |
Follows sole proprietorship or partnership rules, depending on tax status of LLC |