What does training ROI tell us?
Employee training is essential for every company that hopes to succeed. Yet the cost is likewise high. Because of this, the majority of HR and business executives are curious as to whether investment in training is worthwhile. Your company can maximize your training budget expenditures and make the best investments by measuring the return on investment from your training initiatives. Let’s take a closer look at training ROI measurement.
Training Return on Investment (ROI) quantifies the return on an organization’s training investment. It is a monetary measure that breaks down the advantages and commercial results associated with a training initiative. It is not a measure of employee satisfaction with the training, which tells us how satisfied the employees are.
You can determine the financial worth of a given workshop, training course, or leadership program by employing a variety of metrics.
It’s not necessary to use ROI to evaluate every training program. It is actually advised to do this for a mere 5% of training courses. The programs that are offered are determined by the training’s business impact and complexity.
For instance, your business would wish to calculate the return on investment (ROI) for a two-year leadership development program; however, ROI measurement would not be necessary for instruction on the organization’s new code of conduct. Not every training program has a clear return on investment.
To determine training ROI, you would gather information such as:
- Sales information
- Levels of client satisfaction
- Efficiency and production
- Any financial indicator that directly relates to the goal of the company
- Training expenses include those for the teacher, training supplies, facilities, travel, trainee productivity loss, and more.
The following is the fundamental training ROI formula: net benefits – total training expense / total training expense.
Why calculate the training ROI?
- Making the case for investing funds spent on training: Most large-scale training initiatives require approval from your organization’s senior team. Demonstrating the advantages of previous training initiatives will encourage decision-makers to make a confident investment in training.
- Making certain that the training efforts you’re funding are appropriate: You can compare the ROI effects of various trainings by measuring their respective ROIs. In times of financial difficulty, the training budget is typically one of the first things to be trimmed in a business. It is crucial to select the appropriate initiative as you may not have the funds to support every training program.
- Setting priorities: By calculating the return on investment (ROI) of your training programs, you may decide which training investments will have the most effects on improving organizational performance.
- Measuring and demonstrating the value that training has helped create: You have a better chance of getting funding for future training initiatives if you can demonstrate to leadership and other stakeholders the value that training has helped create.
Difficulties in Calculating Training ROI
- Not establishing specific objectives: It’s challenging to demonstrate the training’s impact if your objectives aren’t clear. Furthermore, it creates misunderstandings regarding the information required to demonstrate the ROI.
- Absence of data: Speaking of data, it might be challenging to obtain the various kinds of information needed to calculate training return on investment from various sources. Additionally, you must figure out how to translate facts into monetary terms.
- Separating the training’s effects: Other variables, such as company culture, the state of the market, and others, may also affect the performance that the training is intended to improve. It may be difficult to link the training to the outcomes achieved.
Methods for Calculating Training ROI
We’ll investigate three approaches to training return on investment. So let’s get started:
- The Kirkpatrick Training Evaluation Model
This depends on a four-level approach that may be applied to assess the efficacy of any training program or course:
Level 1: Reaction
Assessing the learners’ answers and reactions to the training is the first step. You’re attempting to figure out the participants’ degree of satisfaction during this process in addition to looking for any trends or potential improvement areas.
Important metrics like completion and participation rates as well as net promoter scores can be gathered. These qualitative data points are easily obtained at the conclusion of a training session or through survey questions.
Level 2: Learning
The learning stage’s aims are to make sure your training has achieved its goals, pinpoint the abilities that learners can acquire from it, and record any new information or abilities that staff members have picked up as a result.
This can be measured by keeping an eye on how well workers perform at work, noting any improvements, and identifying any new talents they may have picked up. At this point, there are numerous approaches to measurement, such as pre- and post-training questionnaires, assessments, and peer reviews.
Level 3: Behavior
The third step evaluates whether and how much the training has changed behavior. Usually, at this point, you track any improvements in staff involvement, motivation, or morale.
Level 4: Impact
Measuring the impact of the training on company objectives and outcomes is the last phase. This is the stage where training ROI is particularly addressed. At the ‘impact’ level, key performance measures include higher customer happiness, staff retention, productivity, sales, and work quality.
Each of these variables can be measured in a different way. Customer satisfaction, for instance, can be assessed by asking customers in focus groups how their experiences have changed over time. If managers see a shift in worker productivity, you can interview them about it. Quantitative data collected over an extended period of time can be used to measure retention rates.
- The Phillips Training Evaluation Model
The Kirkpatrick model is the foundation for the Phillips V-model, which has five stages of training evaluation as follows:
Level 1: Reaction
This stage serves to better understand how individuals have experienced the training course. AI technologies, reviews, pulse surveys, questionnaires, and other methods are used to collect information.
For instance:
Over 300 consultants received sales training from an organization in an effort to increase their effectiveness as sales consultants and to develop their overall business acumen, customer interaction, and negotiation abilities. The business hopes to increase its sales margins over the next three years, and these consultants are part of that goal.
Training participants were emailed a survey as part of the Level 1 evaluation to gauge their degree of satisfaction, the efficacy of the trainer, and the merits of the material presented.
The following are the training outcomes (out of 10):
Effectiveness of the trainer: 8.9
Content quality: 7.5
Levels of satisfaction: 8.2
Level 2: Learning
This stage assesses if the learning objectives of a training program have been satisfied. In other words, it aids in determining whether or not the students have gained the abilities and information that the training was intended to convey.
It also considers attentiveness (whether or not employees were participating in the training) and attendance (if employees were present).
Example: Participants were asked if they believed they had learned a new skill that would be helpful for their job as part of the post-training survey. According to the poll results, over 65% of participants said they had acquired new information or skills.
Level 3: Application
Gathering qualitative data at this point allows you to plan how to enhance your training by gaining insight into how learners apply their newly acquired skills. It also lets you identify the reasons why students didn’t pick up the skills they were meant to. It assists you in determining if the problem sprang from the training’s content and delivery or from potential problems with the organization’s infrastructure.
Example: Using 360-degree feedback, respondents were asked to rate their own “ability to sell” or level of proficiency as a sales consultant in light of the new abilities they had learned. This was given four months following the course to allow enough time for practicing the newly acquired skills. Participants were asked to evaluate themselves as well as their colleagues and managers.
More than 70% of sales consultants thought their abilities had improved their ability to close deals with customers. Plus, eighty-five percent of supervisors thought that training skills were visible. Furthermore, more than 90% of their colleagues reported that the participants’ performance had significantly improved.
Level 4: Impact
The Phillips V-model examines the training’s overall effect on the organization at level four. It takes into account organizational aspects that could make it more difficult for the skills learned during training to be implemented successfully, in addition to attributes that have an impact on the effectiveness of training.
For example, a control group was used to determine whether training was the cause of improved sales skills. The first group received extensive training in sales. The second group had not. Prior to the training, the performance and skill levels of these two groups were similar.
The group that had received training performed noticeably better than the group that had not, according to the results.
Level 5: ROI, or return on investment
Level 5 examines the relationship between training and company outcomes through a variety of calculations, including a cost-benefit analysis.
Example: The performance of the sales consultants—that is, the quantity of sales and revenue from sales—was precisely compared to the training expenditure in order to determine ROI.
The training’s benefit outcome was as much as $3,000 per participant, which allowed researchers to separate out the training’s effects and apply control group data.
The price of training was then taken into account. It came to $1,738 in total after accounting for training materials, facilitation fees, time off work, and travel expenses.
After the costs and benefits were determined, they were entered into the ROI formula:
(3,000 – 1,738) / 1,738 * 100 = an ROI of 72.6%
That represents a 72% overall ROI, which is a great return on training investment.
The last stage is to account for variables that may have an impact on training results. This consists of:
Getting training on the job thanks to a manager who is encouraging.
Recognize training obstacles and take prompt action to overcome them.
Receiving ongoing guidance even after training.
- Impact analysis
Doing a business impact analysis is another way to figure out how profitable your training is. This refers to any changes brought about by the training program. Sales, market share, client feedback, etc. are a few examples.
The four steps to creating a business impact study are listed below.
Evaluation planning
Once you are aware of the impact your study will cover, you can choose the metrics by which to gauge that impact. For instance, you might require sales statistics on the amount of sales, the number of added accounts, or the churn rate.
Next, you must arrange for the acquisition of your training set. This could include the total cost of the program, the number of lessons taught, and the participation rate of employees.
Data gathering
Gather all the information needed to assess the training’s effectiveness at this point. Remember that you may need to collect data from various departments and sources. Make sure you know exactly what you need. For example, find out how many sales there were during the above dates by asking your sales consultant.
In other words, gather pre- and post-training company and financial information (or data related to the skill being taught) alongside training data.
Data interpretation
Determine the monetary value of the gathered data by applying the ROI formula. For instance, you may like to compare the amount of sales made both before and after training, as well as their monetary value.
Reporting
This comprises a report, both qualitative and quantitative, based on the main conclusions drawn from the data analysis. This is the point at which an impact study is assembled and finished.
Practical advice for calculating training ROI
Set your objectives for calculating the return on investment (ROI). Do you want to determine which training has the most impact or do you want to justify the expense of the training? Establishing your goals can assist you in figuring out what information you need and how to calculate ROI.
Decide what data you’ll need early on. You can begin collecting the data, or at least know where to get it from, by figuring out what data you’ll need to measure the return on your training investment.
Establish benchmarks: Your data will be compared to pre-training data. To be able to compare and demonstrate the ROI, you must set standards for the pre-training state. If your sales training aims to raise the average transaction size by 5%, for instance, you have to determine what the typical transaction size is prior to the training. The data from before and after training can then be compared.
Look for methods to separate the training’s impacts. As previously discussed, pinpointing the precise impacts of the training and the potential influence of other factors might be challenging. There are various steps you can take:
- Control group: Contrasting the received-training group with the non-trained group.
- Evaluation of the training’s impact: It is customary to ask trainees and/or their managers to assess the training’s impact in addition to other variables.
- Trend analysis: If you’re examining how training affects sales figures, you can project sales figures based on trends to see what they would be like without training and then compare those figures to those that have received it.
Give yourself ample time to complete the program; results won’t become apparent right away. To perform a useful ROI calculation, figure out how long you will need to wait to see the results.
In sum
It is not an easy task to gather data and do training ROI calculations. To ensure that you’re making the most of your time and effort and that you can actually demonstrate a business impact, you should concentrate on your strategic training programs that support your company’s objectives.