Can I Refuse to Sign a Written Warning at Work?

This article explains whether employees can refuse to sign written warnings and what a signature actually means in workplace discipline. It also covers steps for responding, documenting facts, and protecting your record during performance reviews or disciplinary meetings.

By Douglas Wade, Attorney

Email | Call (800) 484-4610

Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.

Table of Contents

1. Introduction

2. Raise Your Concern

3. Gathering of the Facts

4. Ask for backup

5. Challenging a Performance Review

6. Putting it in writing

7. At-will Employment

8. Write-Ups & Termination

9. Rebuttals

Introduction

A write-up at work can stir up a lot. It can cause shock and frustration. Maybe even a sense that you’ve been blindsided. That feeling gets worse when the record doesn’t match what actually happened, or when context is missing.

In most companies, employees are allowed to respond to write-ups—disciplinary notes and performance reviews included. If you plan to challenge it, slow down and stay professional. Be specific. Address the details. A clear, measured response goes much further than an emotional one.

Raise Your Concern

Many employees pause and wonder: “Can I refuse to sign a written warning?” If a write-up is put in front of you and you don’t agree with it, don’t stay quiet. Say it then and there. Stay calm and straightforward. There is no need to argue.

Example

“I don’t assess it like that. What’s written here leaves out too much and doesn’t match what actually happened. I’d like to respond. First in person, and then in writing. I want to explain my side properly. There’s context missing, and I want the chance to walk through it, point by point, from where I’m standing.”

Sometimes you can talk it out right then and there. Clear things up before anything goes into your file. Other times, you’ll be asked to put your response on paper. Either way, speaking up matters. It puts your manager on notice.

Tip: You may feel upset. It’s acceptable to take a while to react. Tell them that the write-up is not in line with your opinion. Communicate that you are going to submit a written response the next day.

“Can I refuse to sign a written warning?” The answer depends on how your workplace handles discipline and documentation.

Gathering of the Facts

Take the time to pull together anything that supports your version of events. If the issue is tardiness, check your calendar. Look at the dates mentioned. Note when meetings ran long, when absences were already approved, or when you were actually on time. Save emails, meeting notes, or anything that backs that up.

If the claim is “you have missed deadlines”, do the same. Gather emails, project files, timelines—whatever shows what was agreed to and when your work was delivered. If delays came from someone else, make sure you have that trail documented too.

Tip: Email can quietly protect you. Most people don’t think about it until they are in a situation. Start saving important threads. Both the long ones and the boring ones. They matter later.

Ask for backup

If the write-up comes down to one person’s story versus yours, don’t carry it alone. Especially when it involves things like bullying or harassment—stuff that rarely leaves clear evidence behind. Think about who’s seen your day-to-day behavior. Who was there? Who knows how you actually work? A short note from them can help. It adds context. And it reminds people that this isn’t just one voice in the room.

Challenging a Performance Review

When a write-up is tied to a performance review—and especially when it claims you’re missing the mark in important areas— your response should be sharp and to the point. Reviews aren’t the place for fuzzy language or throwaway comments.

If your manager says something like, “You are not trying enough,” don’t let it sit there. Ask for real examples. Things like dates and situations. If they can’t point to any, make sure that gap is noted in your response.

Wherever possible, bring facts to the table. If you’re told you didn’t hit last quarter’s goals, show the numbers that say otherwise. Sales reports, metrics, completed projects—use whatever proves your case. Then walk through the write-up line by line. Explain why you do not agree with each point.

Example

“I don’t agree with the paragraph which says that “I’m not a team player”. I’ve attached four peer reviews and two company awards that reflect the opposite.”

If your boss asks you to sign a write-up and it doesn’t sit right with you, slow things down. You don’t have to agree in that moment. Take a breath. Ask for time to write a rebuttal. Understand what that signature really means if you do sign it. It only shows that the document has been received. It doesn’t mean you agree with its content.

Warning: Flat-out refusing to sign a write-up can create a new problem on its own. Some employers treat that as insubordination. Step back and look honestly at what happened. If you were at fault (even in a small way), say it. Acknowledge the mistake. Explain how you’ll correct it. What you’ll do differently in the future. Then follow it up in writing. Ask that your statement be placed in your file with the write-up.

Before refusing outright, ask yourself: “Can I refuse to sign a written warning without creating a separate issue like insubordination?”

Putting it in writing

When an employer decides you’re not meeting expectations, they often put it in writing. Sometimes it’s about performance. Other times it’s behavior—arguing with coworkers, refusing instructions, things like that. Either way, it ends up documented.

That document doesn’t disappear into a drawer. It becomes part of your file. A trail. One that can be used later, especially if the company wants a reason to let you go. And it doesn’t always stop there. From a legal standpoint, those records can matter down the line, even when you’re looking for your next job.

That’s why they ask you to sign it. Not because you agree—just to show you’ve seen it. It feels like a binary choice most of the time. Sign it or refuse. But what if what’s written isn’t accurate? What if you don’t want your signature anywhere near it? Before getting into what you can do next, it helps to understand a few basic employment law ideas that shape how write-ups are actually treated.

When people ask, “Can I refuse to sign a written warning?” what they’re really asking is whether a signature equals agreement. It doesn’t.

At-will Employment

In every state except Montana, most workers are considered at-will employees. That means an employer can fire someone for almost any reason, at almost any time, without giving advance notice. It cuts both ways. Employees can also walk away without explaining themselves or giving notice. Still, at-will isn’t absolute—there are limits.

At-will employment has become the norm across the U.S. But employers don’t have to stick to it. Some choose to use formal employment contracts, and those agreements can place restrictions on when and how either side can end the relationship.

Unions change the picture as well. Through collective bargaining, they can negotiate terms that override parts of at-will employment. And on top of all that, state and federal laws still set boundaries on when an employer can legally terminate someone.

Write-Ups & Termination

What you get written up for usually depends on where you work. In retail, it might be attendance or taking too many breaks. In a factory setting, it’s often about quality checks or production issues. Same idea, different environment.

Most of the time, a write-up shows up after a verbal warning hasn’t fixed the problem. It’s the employer’s way of saying, “We talked about this already.”

They may not bother with warnings at all and move straight to termination if the issue is serious. You can challenge that if you believe it was unfair or unlawful. It’s not as simple as people think. You may speak with an employment attorney and get a clear picture of the various available options.

Rebuttals

If you’re asking: “Can I refuse to sign a written warning?”, remember that a written rebuttal still gives you a voice on record. Don’t skim a write-up. Read every line. Figure out exactly what they’re accusing you of and which company rule they say you broke. Usually, it’s handed to you by your manager, sometimes by HR. Either way, the paper matters.

Performance reviews work much the same way. Someone sits you down, walks through the review, and explains any discipline that showed up over the year. Nothing in there is random, even if it feels that way.

A lot of these documents aren’t asking you to agree with them. They’re just confirming you saw them. That’s why the language usually says “acknowledged”. It points you to the employee handbook instead of asking for approval.

You can respond in writing if you don’t agree with what’s written. HR is supposed to keep that response with the original write-up. It becomes part of your file too—your version, on record, sitting right next to theirs.

Have a quick question? We answered nearly 2000 FAQs.

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment

Most recent blogs:

Is Weight Discrimination Illegal in California? A Clear Look at Protections, Risks, and Employer Duties

California weight discrimination law often hinges on disability and medical condition rules under FEHA rather than explicit weight protections. Employers face growing risk from assumptions, accommodation missteps, and workplace comments as courts and cities broaden enforcement standards.

Can I Refuse to Sign a Written Warning at Work?

Is Nepotism Illegal in California? What the Law Allows and Prohibits

California nepotism laws differ between private employers and public agencies, explaining when family favoritism is allowed and when it violates law. This article explains discrimination risks, protected classes, and employee options when favoritism crosses into unlawful conduct.

Salary Requirements California: Minimum Pay, Exempt Status, and Overtime Rules

California salary requirements cover minimum pay, exempt status, overtime rules, and equal pay standards for salaried and non-exempt workers. This article explains minimum wage levels, exemption thresholds, local wage differences, pay cuts, and legal claims under California labor laws.

Borello Test Explained: Worker Classification Rules in California

This article explains the Borello test and ABC test used for worker classification decisions under California employment law. It outlines when each test applies, key factors reviewed by EDD, and why proper classification affects taxes and worker benefits.

California Criminal Background Check 7-Year Rule: How It Affects Old Felony Records

See how California's 7-year background check rule affects old felony records, employment chances, housing access, and licensing opportunities. Find legal options like expungement, certificates of rehabilitation, pardons, and Clean Slate reforms to limit long-term damage from past convictions.

How to Get Your Guard Card in California: Training, Steps, and Requirements

Get your California guard card with step-by-step guidance on BSIS requirements, mandatory training hours, applications, and background checks. Stay updated on rule changes, online versus in-person courses, timelines, and qualifications for unarmed security guard positions.

Vacation Pay for Salaried Employees in California: Rights, Accrual Rules, and Payout Requirements

Find out how California salaried employees accrue vacation pay, keep unused PTO, and claim payout when employment ends. See common employer tactics limiting vacation benefits, plus FAQs on sick leave, caps, holiday pay, and final paycheck rights.

California Salary Threshold 2026: Minimum Wage Increase, Exempt Employee Rules, and Compliance Checklist

Stay on top of the California Salary Threshold 2026, the $16.90 minimum wage, and exempt employee pay rules. Use this practical checklist to update payroll, adjust classifications, refresh postings, and reduce wage-and-hour compliance risks in 2026.

How Long Do Employers Have to Keep W-2s: Record Retention Rules for Businesses

Find out how long employers must keep W-2s and other tax records to stay compliant with IRS retention rules. Protect your business from penalties by organizing employment tax documents, payroll files, and historical returns for the recommended periods.

PAGA Notice Statute of Limitations: California Deadlines for Filing Claims

Get a concise overview of California PAGA notice statute of limitations, one-year filing deadlines, and Labor Agency review periods. See how late filing, defective notice, or ongoing wage violations can affect eligibility and outcomes for representative PAGA claims.

California Class Action Lawsuit Basics for Workers and Consumers

Get a clear overview of California class action lawsuits, including how they work for workers and consumers seeking compensation. Find out about typical case types, key legal requirements, settlement outcomes, and the benefits and risks of joining a class.

Meal Break Waiver in California: What Employees Can Agree To

California meal break waiver rules explain when workers may skip lunch and when employers must provide uninterrupted, off-duty meal periods. See how waiver agreements, on-duty meals, and penalty pay work so employees protect rights and businesses follow California labor law.

Predictive Scheduling Laws: State and City Requirements for Employers

Get an overview of U.S. predictive scheduling laws, including covered industries, key city and state rules, penalties, and employer obligations. See which jurisdictions require advance work schedules, how predictability pay works, and how HR software supports compliance with these regulations.

Harassment Training Requirements California: Employer Deadlines, Who Must Train, and Refresher Rules

Get up-to-date California harassment training requirements for employers, including who must train, deadlines, and refresher timelines. Avoid common compliance mistakes by following California rules on sexual harassment training, protected classes, policy obligations, and required documentation.

Inside Sales Exemption California: Rules on Pay, Breaks, and Commissions

Straightforward information on California's inside sales exemption, including rules on pay, overtime, breaks, commissions, and federal FLSA requirements. See how misclassification affects overtime, meal and rest breaks, back pay, and when to contact a California employment lawyer.

How Many Hours Can a Volunteer Work per Day in California? Laws, Limits, and Rights Explained

Find out how many hours volunteers can work per day in California under labor rules, protections, and scheduling limits. Compare volunteer and employee rights, including workers' compensation, harassment protections, discrimination safeguards, and key considerations for nonprofit and public organizations.

Show Up Pay California: Employee Rights for Being Sent Home Early or Given Short Shifts

Show up pay California explains employee rights to reporting time pay when sent home early or given short shifts. Review rules, exceptions, examples, and options for unpaid wages or retaliation claims if your employer ignores California reporting time laws.

Can Managers Take Tips in California? Laws, Tip Pools & SB 648

Can managers take tips in California, and what does Labor Code Section 351 say about tip pooling and supervisors? Find out how SB 648 strengthens enforcement against tip theft, helps workers recover withheld gratuities, and increases penalties for violations.

Can Owners Take Tips in California? A Complete Guide to State Tip Laws and Employee Rights

Find out when California business owners can share in tips, how tip pooling works, and minimum wage obligations. Get a breakdown of employee tip rights, illegal practices, service charges, penalties, and protection options for California workers.

Right to Disconnect Laws in California: AB 2751 for Employers and Employees

See how California's AB 2751 right to disconnect bill could reshape after-hours communication between employers and employees. Review potential effects on work-life balance, stress, productivity, and compliance planning as organizations anticipate possible enforcement.

Defamation California: Key Laws, Legal Defenses, and Damages Explained

Get an overview of California defamation law, including libel, slander, negligence standards, and the difference between public and private figures. Review key defenses, retraction rules, and available damages such as actual, compensatory, punitive, and emotional distress awards.

What Is a Level 1 Background Check and How It Differs from Level 2

See what a Level 1 background check covers and how it compares with a Level 2 screening for hiring. Get clear facts on definitions, state lookback limits, and how better screening supports safer workplaces and less fraud.

California Vacation Rollover Law: Employee Rights, Accrued Time, and Pay Rules

This article covers California vacation rollover rules, employee rights, accrued PTO, payout duties, and employer limits under state law. It explains how unused vacation counts as wages, when employers must pay it out, and options for unpaid wage claims.

SB 553 CA: New Workplace Violence Prevention Requirements for California Employers in 2025

Get a clear overview of California SB 553 workplace violence prevention rules and new obligations for employers starting in 2025. See what policies, training, recordkeeping, and enforcement changes SB 553 brings for injury prevention plans and compliance efforts.

Labor Code 226.7: California Meal and Rest Break Requirements and Employer Penalties

California Labor Code 226.7 explains meal and rest break rules for non-exempt employees and what employers must pay when breaks stop. See how missed breaks trigger premium pay, wage claims, penalties, and class actions for violations of California break requirements.

Building an Onboarding Packet That Welcomes and Retains Employees

Create an onboarding packet that welcomes new hires, sets clear expectations, and supports lasting engagement and retention. Include culture details, training tools, policies, and thoughtful gifts to lower turnover and reduce hiring costs.

Complete Guide to New Employee Paperwork: Required Forms and Documents for 2025

Make new employee paperwork for 2025 easier with a clear checklist of required hiring forms, documents, and compliance steps. Support HR and small business owners with practical tips for organizing onboarding packets, benefit elections, direct deposit, and policy acknowledgments.

Paid Time Off California: Laws, Accrual, Vacation Pay, and Employee Rights

Get clear guidance on paid time off in California, including PTO laws, sick leave rules, accrual, and vacation payout obligations. See how California PTO rules affect vacation requests, paid sick leave, layoffs, FTE status, cash-outs, and employee rights.

Can employers test for THC in California for hiring and workplace safety?

See when California employers may test workers for THC under AB 2188 without violating state protections for off-duty cannabis use. Review allowed testing methods, safety-sensitive role policies, and steps to align workplace drug testing programs with current impairment standards.

See all blogs: Business | Corporate | Employment

Can I Refuse to Sign a Written Warning at Work?

Introduction

Raise Your Concern

Gathering of the Facts

Ask for backup

Challenging a Performance Review

Putting it in writing

At-will Employment

Write-Ups & Termination

Rebuttals

Free Consultation